It is not altogether fair for the Secretary of State to charge hon. members on this side of the House with being indefinite in-their criticism. I think they have been very definite. My hon. friend from West Lamfoton (Mr. Pardee) has given him a specific case, which he has not been able to answer. My hon. friend from Richmond (Mr. Kyte) has given him another specific case, well known in eastern Nova Scotia and Prince Edward Island. He has made no reply. My hon. friend from Pictou (M;. Macdonald) has mentioned another case ;n the town of Stellarton. The Secretary of State has not been able to answer any of these. If he wants another case, I will give him a fourth.