April 17, 1918

SECRET SESSION OF THE HOUSE.


The House, in conformity with a resolution, agreed to on motion of the Right Hon. the Prime Minister on Monday, the 15th day of April inst., went into secret session, until the House should otherwise order. At the conclusion of the secret session, the following report of its proceedings was issued under the authority of Mr. Speaker. "The Prime Minister, on a motion to go into Committee of Supply, made a full statement surveying the present war situation. treating of the military position, the supply and production of foodstuffs, and the problem of merchant shipping and the submarine, with especial reference to the man-power position of the British Empire and the Allies. "He stated that the Government, being impressed with the desirability of giving to t'he House the fullest possible information had communicated to the Prime Minister of the United Kingdom its intention to move for a secret session and had requested from Mr. Lloyd George a statement of the present position which might be made known to the House. Mr. Lloyd George's message in response to this request was then read. "The Prime Minister then presented other information and considerations' bearing on the situation. The military position confronting the Empire was explained in detail. The enemy had clearly disclosed his intention to make a supreme effort to destroy the British army on the western front as an effective fighting force. To this end he had adopted measures placing every man in the German Empire between the ages of 17 and 60 at the disposal of the Government, reducing the age limit for military service, and re-organizing his formations in the field. His forces and reserves for striking at the western front had been enormously increased by the withdrawal of Russia from the war. The employment of Landwehr and Landsturm formations for the defence of the eastern front, the use of these formations to supply individual men as drafts to replace casualties in France and Flanders, their places being taken in turn by the youngest recruits for purposes of training, the cessation of war wastage in the East, and the transfer in addition of large numbers of Austro-Hungarian troops-considering all these factors, the Russian withdrawal had increased the potential enemy strength on the western front, including 'Italy, by possibly -as many as 1,600,000 men without taking into account the reserves which would otherwise have been necessary for the Russian front. "France had made already enormous sacrifices, and she would continue her heroic and glorious effort to the end. "The Government of the United Kingdom had accordingly initiated the most drastic measures for maintaining their effective forces and providing the necessary reserves for the future. "The military effort already made by the United Kingdom, France and the Dominions was shown by means of detailed confidential information as to the strength of the forces which have been raised by each. "As to the position confronting this Dominion, it was apparent that an attack upon the Canadian Army -corps in full force must be expected. No one could say when, but in view of the strategic value of their position there could be no doubt they must be prepared to meet any attack launched by the enemy and the country must be prepared to provide the reinforcements to make good all losses. The Government had been in communication with the overseas military authorities, and as the result of the most careful consideration the clear conclusion had been reached that if the Canadian Army corps- was to be maintained as an effective fighting force, additional measures must be taken. The Canadian Army corps must be maintained; no one -could question that. There was therefore no other alternative before the Government but to propose further measures for recruiting the needed reinforcements. These measures had been formulated and announced. "With regard to the shipping situation, the Prime Minister pointed out that allied and neutral ocean-going tonnage, estimated at 33,000,000 tons at the beginning of the war, had been reduced at the end of 1917 by a net loss of 2,500,000 tons, that is, about 8 per cent; while British tonnage, considered separately, had suffered a reduction of 20 per cent, the tonnage being 18,000,000 tons at the outbreak of war and the net loss, taking into account new construction as in the other case, being 3,500,000 tons. "The strain on British shipping was illustrated by a citation of the very large proportion which is devoted to the special war services of the army, navy, the Allies and the British Dominions. The result was a very serious reduction in the amount available for supplying the United Kingdom with its essential foods and materials and the sacrifices imposed upon the people of Great Britain could not be overstated. The shipbuilding programme of the Empire and the Allies was explained. The important question of the world's food supply was reviewed and the House was made acquainted with information pointing to the vital neoessit-y for stimulating increased production. "In conclusion the Prime Minister urged that it must be recognized that the position was one of extreme gravity. In view of the issues involved Germany must be defeated. There could be no other alternative. And to this end Canada must provide all the



assistance in her power. We must supply the men necessary to keep our divisions up to full strength no matter what casualties were suffered, and we must so organize our remaining human power as to maintain and if possible increase our agricultural production. "Following the Prime Minister's statement a brief discussion ensued, those who took part in it being Sir Wilfrid Laurier, Sir Sam Hughes and General Mewburn. "The memlbers of the Senate attended the session, that House having adjourned for the purpose." And at five minutes past five of the clock in the afternoon, the House having so ordered, the doors were opened.


YUKON ACT AMENDMENT.


On motion of Hon. Arthur Meighen, (Minister of the Inertior), Bill 39, to amend the Yukon Act, was read the third time, and passed.


DOMINION BUREAU OF STATISTICS.


On motion of Sir George Foster (Minister of Trade and Commerce) Bill 32, respecting the Dominion Bureau of Statistics, was read the third time and passed.


COMPENSATION FOR INJURIES TO GOVERNMENT EMPLOYEES.

UNION

John Dowsley Reid (Minister of Railways and Canals)

Unionist

Hon. J. D. REID (Minister of Railways) moved:

Third reading of Bill No. 51, to provide compensation where employees of His Majesty are killed or suffer injuries while performing their duty.

Mr. JACQUES BUREAU (Three Rivers) . It is provided by the Bill that Government employees of each province shall be treated the same as ordinary employees, coming within the Employers' Liability and the Workmen's Compensation Act. The 'question arose yesterday as to how we should designate the Crown when we desire to bring an action and desire to summon the King. The summons is in the name of the King, and it will be the King summoning the King. I would suppose that if a man worked tor the Public Works Department the fact of his bringing an action against the Public Works Department would be sufficient without any service. Could the Minister of the Interior explain as to that?

Topic:   COMPENSATION FOR INJURIES TO GOVERNMENT EMPLOYEES.
Permalink
UNION

Arthur Meighen (Minister of the Interior; Superintendent-General of Indian Affairs)

Unionist

Hon. ARTHUR MEIGHEN:

It was suggested that the Governor in Council might by regulation determine the title of the defendant and what should constitute service on the Crown. It would then be within the

power of the Governor in Council to say that the department concerned might be the defendant. The reason I did not see fit to recommend that the suggestion be followed was that there might well be injuries sustained by employees who could not be said to be employees of any department, but still were employees of the Government of Canada,

Topic:   COMPENSATION FOR INJURIES TO GOVERNMENT EMPLOYEES.
Permalink
L LIB

Jacques Bureau

Laurier Liberal

Mr. BUREAU:

It is all left with the Governor in Council. Suppose a man is injured on a public work, where will he serve the King? Will it be the Department of Public Works?

Topic:   COMPENSATION FOR INJURIES TO GOVERNMENT EMPLOYEES.
Permalink
UNION

Arthur Meighen (Minister of the Interior; Superintendent-General of Indian Affairs)

Unionist

Mr. MEIGHEN:

That is covered by the Bill.

Topic:   COMPENSATION FOR INJURIES TO GOVERNMENT EMPLOYEES.
Permalink
L LIB

Jacques Bureau

Laurier Liberal

Mr. BUREAU:

I think the Bill is a step in the right direction, but the way in which the King ought to be summoned and the place where he should be served ought to be designated in this Bill. It is a question of procedure, and the provision should be in the statute so that we should not have to go to the official Gazette, or write to the Clerk of the Privy Council, to get a copy of the order, to determine by what procedure this law is to be put in force, or in what way the King can Jae summoned or where he can be summoned. A few words added to the Bill would make the required provision. However, iif it is going to delay the passage of the Bill, I am willing to drop the matter.

Topic:   COMPENSATION FOR INJURIES TO GOVERNMENT EMPLOYEES.
Permalink
UNION

John Dowsley Reid (Minister of Railways and Canals)

Unionist

Hon. J. D. REID:

After the discussion last night, it was thought wrell that a clause should be inserted .giving the Governor in Council power to 'say on whom the service should be made.

Topic:   COMPENSATION FOR INJURIES TO GOVERNMENT EMPLOYEES.
Permalink
UNION

Edgar Nelson Rhodes (Speaker of the House of Commons)

Unionist

Mr. SPEAKER:

I have allowed some laxity in the proceedings to-day, in order that the hon. member might obtain the information he desires, but. the minister, having moved the third reading, he has exhausted his right to speak.

Topic:   COMPENSATION FOR INJURIES TO GOVERNMENT EMPLOYEES.
Permalink
L LIB
UNION

Edgar Nelson Rhodes (Speaker of the House of Commons)

Unionist

Mr. SPEAKER:

The hon. member for Three Rivers (Mr. Bureau) has also exhausted Ibis right to speak.

Topic:   COMPENSATION FOR INJURIES TO GOVERNMENT EMPLOYEES.
Permalink
L LIB

Pius Michaud

Laurier Liberal

Mr. PIUS MICHAUD (Restigoucbe and Madawaska):

I desire to endorse the views expressed by the hon. member for Three Rivers with reference to this Bill. Hon. gentlemen can imagine for a moment an attorney conducting a case for a certain client, having to write to the Department of Justice, or to the Clerk of the Privy Council, for information as to whom he should address himself in presenting the

petition .in the name of his client. It would only require the insertion of a few words in tlhe Bill. 11 understand this Bill is in aid of .all parties who receive injuries on Government works, and I understand the provisions are ini line with the compensation Acts oif the different provinces. Under those Acts, attorneys or solicitors are limited .in their costs; they simply draw up one petition, and address it to the court, and then the Judge sets the case down for hearing. But under this Bill we have to hunt around and find to whom we should address ourselves, .and how we should obtain information as to the proceedings. Of course we should endeavour to save costs, in the interests of those seeking compensation. This matter should be definitely provided for in the Bill, and make it a precedent for all time.

Topic:   COMPENSATION FOR INJURIES TO GOVERNMENT EMPLOYEES.
Permalink

Motion agreed to, and Bill read the third time.


RAILWAY BELT ACT AMENDMENT.

April 17, 1918